Best Pizza in New York

Scarr’s is a solid spot for a legit NY pizza experience! The back seating area makes it feel like a proper sit-down meal, and the bar’s a chill vibe—perfect for sipping a 🍺 beer and grabbing a slice. The classic NY cheese slice was good, but the Sicilian square stole the show with its crispy, flavorful crust. The Hot Boi brought some 🔥 spice with hot honey that hit just right, and the pepperoni had those perfect crispy, cupped edges. The sauce is savory, not too heavy, and the dough’s crisp, though I’d love a touch more salt. Service was fast, and the bartender was super friendly. Plenty of seating and clean restrooms make it stand out. It’s not my top NYC slice, but I’d swing by again for the vibe and that Sicilian! 🍕

The cheese slice was truly special. One of the best I've had in the city. We had eaten dinner before so we split a slice - suffice to say, we inhaled it and cannot wait to return. Recently I went again and dined inside since the queue outside is crazy long. Greet service and all the pies we tried were wholesome. We got the Margherita (highly recommend), a vegan pie, and the dr Clark Kent (Sicilian) - all blew us away. The hotboi was the most popular one though we didn't try it

First I have to start off by saying that Mia is Amazing!! We found this place by accident waiting on another place to seat us and we were so glad we did. We knew it was great when we saw a line out the door and we were right. The vodka pesto slice was so fresh and so firm and crispy with the perfect amount and balance of flavor. We loved the pizza and a place I would definitely recommend. We sat at the bar and were immediately greeted by Mia. She was friendly attentive and continually checked on us. We told her we were visiting from Vegas and she thrilled us with the news that a new Scarrs opened in Vegas, YAY!!!! She sat there and talked to us and made us feel so welcomed. Hypothetically if the pizza was not good, I would go there just to support her. The vibe was chill because it was only 2 pm when we went but I can only imagine how exciting this place gets at night. I came to NY to try all sorts of different pizza places and this place did not disappoint. So glad we stumbled upon it. A place I would recommend for service, and great pizza made with quality ingredients. I read that they mill their own flour but I wasn't surprised because I can tasted the freshness. Great job Mia and Scarrs team!

Great slice shop with seating for a real sit-down dining experience in back. Sauce is somewhat savory, in contrast to a lot of other New York slices. I thought the plain cheese was okay, but the Sicilian was much better, flavorful and a little crispy. Both were reheated, and I suspect either would be better when fresh from the oven.